Reviews and Comments

Thom Locked account

Thom@kirja.casa

Joined 2 years, 7 months ago

At any given time, I am probably reading one book in paper form, another as an audio book, and another on an e-reader. I also keep an anthology or collection in my car, for those long waits. My average rating is between 3 and 4, because I try to seek out good books and authors. One goal is to read all the SF award winners and SF Masterworks. See my profile at Worlds Without End.

Finally, the "social media" info - I am a long-time reader, proud to have completed several summer reading programs as a kid. I recall reading more than 50 books one summer. When I'm not reading, you might find me gaming (board and role play) or working, either as a baseball umpire or with software.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Carl Hiaasen: Hoot (2002, Alfred A. Knopf, Distributed by Random House)

Roy, who is new to his small Florida community, becomes involved in another boy's attempt …

Review of 'Hoot' on 'Goodreads'

Read this one with my daughter with many breaks (and a library fine) in the middle. This book deserved better than that, so here is my brief recommendation. Go read it!

Middle school topic and guessable plot are the only downsides. Main characters are marvelous, bit parts are wonderful caricatures. Can't go wrong with a kid called "Mullet Fingers"! Beneath the simple plot is a strong message for the environment and some cute owls - understandable as the author is a Florida resident and strong advocate for the Everglades.

I have read that the evisceration of certain characters here (the developer, the corrupt politician) is typical for this author. Having never read Carl Hiaasen before this, I look forward to trying out some more of his work.

Lisa Rogak: Angry Optimist (2015)

Review of 'Angry Optimist' on 'Goodreads'

After writing a biography of Stephen Colbert ([b:And Nothing But the Truthiness: The Rise (and Further Rise) of Stephen Colbert|11167400|And Nothing But the Truthiness The Rise (and Further Rise) of Stephen Colbert|Lisa Rogak|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1317794065s/11167400.jpg|16091535]), author and New York Times columnist Lisa Rogak was destined to tackle the man at the top. His very private nature must have made this task more difficult, so this book reads more like a breakdown of the Daily Show.

Published in December of 2014 while Stewart was still with the show, this bio seems scattered at times. Some personal details (meeting his wife, birth of their kids) are mentioned in passing, but more as a possible explanation for softening his tone on the show. The best part of the book is the beginning (Jon's standup comic work) but even that is from the outside looking in.

This book wasn't bad, but it was just okay.

Thomas Levenson: The Hunt for Vulcan : . . . and How Albert Einstein Destroyed a Planet, Discovered Relativity, and Deciphered the Universe (2015)

Review of 'The Hunt for Vulcan : . . . and How Albert Einstein Destroyed a Planet, Discovered Relativity, and Deciphered the Universe' on 'Goodreads'

One way to think of this is as a biography of the planet Vulcan, zeroth planet in our solar system.

It was born in an 1859 paper by Le Verrier (who discovered Neptune using only mathematics and astronomical observations of Uranus) as the story behind Mercury's perihelion advance. It's troubled childhood include hiding from astronomers and a claimed sighting by French physician and amateur astronomer Edmond Lescarbault. After being declared missing (and presumed dead) in 1878, the scientific community basically ignored the discrepancy in Sir Isaac Newton's system of the world until finally Albert Einstein came along to declare that poor Vulcan had never existed.

That discrepancy between Newtonian orbital mechanics and one described by the general theory of relativity are the focus of this short book, which also delves into the stories of the men involved. No serious math is required, though I felt the author rushed through the …

Amy Krouse Rosenthal: Textbook Amy Krouse Rosenthal (2016)

Review of 'Textbook Amy Krouse Rosenthal' on 'Goodreads'

FTC Compliance - this review of of Textbook Amy Krouse Rosenthal is for an Advanced Reader Copy received from the author.

This author is a textbook case of positivism, and this book is her latest attempt to reach out and touch her audience, making their lives better.

I enjoyed the layout much more than her previous book, [b:Encyclopedia of an Ordinary Life|39872|Encyclopedia of an Ordinary Life|Amy Krouse Rosenthal|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1388254638s/39872.jpg|39574]. The various anecdotes and experiences are categorized into "subjects", which could allow the reader to set their own course curriculum. I read it in the presented way, mostly smiling and occasionally laughing out loud.

Similar to earlier projects of [a:Amy Krouse Rosenthal|21674|Amy Krouse Rosenthal|https://d.gr-assets.com/authors/1448918468p2/21674.jpg], she wants you to be a part of the fun. Interactive text messages and a website complement the text in an excellent way.

I read this book entirely within the scope of a vacation with friends (of more …

reviewed Foundation and Earth by Isaac Asimov (Foundation, #5)

Isaac Asimov: Foundation and Earth (Paperback, 2004, Spectra)

Golan Trevize, Janov Pelorat, Bliss go looking for earth.

Review of 'Foundation and Earth' on 'Goodreads'

Book four, written 30 years after the first three, had a rather abrupt ending, and unsatisfied questions - where is Earth? who was actively hiding it? how does it factor into history and the present day?

So book five was inevitable, and it does answer the above questions. Unfortunately, it does so with a meandering plot, openly fractious characters and somewhat tenuous connections to the rest of Isaac Asimov's books - most importantly the Robots series. One major character from those books makes an appearance at the very end of this book.

Like book four, this was told as one story instead of two, and now with only one point of view. What worked so well for me in the series early on was dropped. The only other mechanical complaint was that the book was quite long, meandering at times. Not only were openly hostile characters not fun to read, …

Grady Klein, Alan Dabney: The Cartoon Introduction to Statistics (2013, Hill & Wang Inc.,U.S.)

Review of 'The Cartoon Introduction to Statistics' on 'Goodreads'

Not the [b:The Cartoon Guide to Statistics|168872|The Cartoon Guide to Statistics|Larry Gonick|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1347462819s/168872.jpg|163075], but an introduction, which it handles well. In the latter chapters, it moves beyond introduction into basic inference and then throws ideas out quickly - the explanations are lacking.

I haven't read Gonick's book, but in this the artwork is rough, at times hard to tell the characters apart. They aren't integral to the main point, but... confusion is not what you want while teaching statistics.

Overall rating - okay, maybe good, not great. A 2 star rating falls within the 95% confidence range.

Jeff Passan: The Arm: Inside the Billion-Dollar Mystery of the Most Valuable Commodity in Sports (2016, Harper)

Review of 'The Arm: Inside the Billion-Dollar Mystery of the Most Valuable Commodity in Sports' on 'Goodreads'

This book is a long series of articles interspersed with a bit too much Todd Coffey and Daniel Hudson, and doesn't live up to it's subtitle. Let me explain.

Many chapters are along the lines of articles from a journal - popular mechanics for instance. These are often interesting, though they draw few conclusions. For an article, that's fine, but I found it a bit frustrating as a chapter.

In this book, we learn about kids that require surgery, over and under use among kids and adults, and a history of the procedure. We go further back in history to our simian relatives and forward to repeat surgeries, with a side trip to Jon Lester's free agency. We receive a glimpse at the year-long rehab (would have liked more here) and a good discussion of injuries in Japanese baseball. Two more interesting chapters examine alternative remedies and strengthening exercises to …

ND Stevenson: Nimona (Hardcover, 2015, HarperTeen)

From the Publisher:

A National Book Award Longlist Title

The graphic novel debut from rising …

Review of 'Nimona' on 'Goodreads'

A successful webcomic collected into a graphic novel containing the whole story. This is good (easier to read with no connection) and not so great (early artwork not as good as later; problems with the backstory (for example) more obvious). I liked the book and hope to read something more (and better planned) by the author soon. Favorite quote - "I'M A SHAAAAAAARK!"

Review of 'Feature Development for Social Networking' on 'Goodreads'

A humorous story, juxtaposing social networking posts or messages with internal memos from the company developing features for said social network. Set in the context of a (controllable?) zombie infection.

Read online at www.tor.com/2013/11/13/feature-development-for-social-networking/ and the artwork leading off the page does nothing for the story.

My review - I liked the background and characters, but the only real resolution is "development complete", which leaves me flat.

Robert Harris: Conspirata (2010, Simon & Schuster)

Internationally bestselling author: "Imperium" was hailed as "quite possibly Harris's most accomplished work to date" …

Review of 'Conspirata' on 'Goodreads'

The first volume ([b:Imperium: A Novel of Ancient Rome|243601|Imperium A Novel of Ancient Rome (Cicero, #1)|Robert Harris|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1442657816s/243601.jpg|1237325]) dealt with the rise of a hungry Cicero, whose wit and legal tactics impelled him to the office of Consul. This novel deals with the aftermath - death threats and a conspiracy while in office, the rise of Caesar and the founding of the Triumvirate. This Cicero has his power nibbled away and rests on his laurels for a bit too long while the Roman Republic crumbles around him. The story ends with the flight into exile.

The first two volumes make up Cicero's early career, though I would have liked a few more speeches. While the writing is still good, the story drags a bit in the second half, and I had to fight to stay interested. There is a third volume that arrived last year ([b:Dictator|25488982|Dictator (Cicero, #3)|Robert Harris|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1442418779s/25488982.jpg|43767637]) which probably …

John Sandford, Ctein: Saturn Run (2015, G.P. Putnam's Sons)

The year is 2066. A Caltech intern inadvertently notices an anomaly from a space telescope—something …

Review of 'Saturn Run' on 'Goodreads'

Somewhat similar to [b:Rendezvous with Rama|112537|Rendezvous with Rama (Rama, #1)|Arthur C. Clarke|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1405456427s/112537.jpg|1882772] or [b:The Martian|18007564|The Martian|Andy Weir|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1413706054s/18007564.jpg|21825181], but with more people.

Not far removed from [b:The Abyss|40289|The Abyss|Orson Scott Card|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1423648046s/40289.jpg|937985], but much drier.

Has aspects of the [b:2010: Odyssey Two|70539|2010 Odyssey Two (Space Odyssey, #2)|Arthur C. Clarke|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1388271989s/70539.jpg|615175] or [b:The Hunt for Red October|19691|The Hunt for Red October (Jack Ryan Universe, #4)|Tom Clancy|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1281995542s/19691.jpg|1112006], but focused on the Chinese.

This science fiction thriller is set a plausible 50 years in the future, and concludes with a few short pages explaining how they extrapolated the technology and outcomes. I enjoyed the characters, I didn't enjoy the early infodumps, but once both were introduced the novel really started rolling. This is a big book, but it kept me coming back for more.

Does it live up to it's glowing blurbs? Maybe. Let's put it this way - don't read the book for these borderline …

No cover

Steve Olson: Eruption (2016)

For months in early 1980, scientists, journalists, sightseers, and nearby residents listened anxiously to rumblings …

Review of 'Eruption' on 'Goodreads'

Author Steve Olson set out to tell the story of most of the 57 people who died as a result of the May 18th eruption, and in doing so he incorporates a lot of history. Several had a connection to logging, and Weyerhauser owned land that abutted the prohibited zones, so a history of that company starts off the book. Science, economy, and the politics of 1980 also factor into this comprehensive story.

The eruption and aftermath are clearly detailed, along with speculations of the final moments of those who died. Interspersed are narratives of some who escaped, burned and bruised. Maps, charts and photographs provide a visual context of the area and event.

Ten years after the fact, my roommates and I drove to the mountain for the first time, parking at what would become the Windy Ridge viewpoint. From there we hiked towards and up the lower slope, …

reviewed Way station by Clifford D. Simak (Collier nucleus fantasy & science fiction)

Clifford D. Simak: Way station (1993, Collier Books, Maxwell Macmillan Canada, Maxwell Macmillan International)

Review of 'Way station' on 'Goodreads'

This is optimistic science fiction, and it has also been referred to as pastoral.

Shortly after the American Civil War, Enoch Wallace was selected to be the station keeper for a galactic relay located here on Earth. He only ages when he is outside the station, collecting the mail or tending his garden, so by the 1960s there are a few questions from the government and one of his Wisconsin neighbors. This novel details his work, using flashbacks and recollections to insert important points. Earth and Galactic politics are nearing a crisis point at the time of the story.

This is the sort of book that inserts itself into your own thoughts and dreams, and for me that includes comparisons with the Highlander, another man living outside society. If it were me, the Way Station would be more like an English Pub. I loved the descriptions of Enoch's land and …

William Gibson (unspecified): Mona Lisa Overdrive (Paperback, German language, 2000, Heyne)

Review of 'Mona Lisa Overdrive' on 'Goodreads'

Reread of a classic in the relatively new genre of Cyberpunk. First read this in the mid 80s and was pretty impressed.

William Gibson, essentially a luddite in his early career, banged this story out on a 1927 portable typewriter, olive green. This sort of descriptive imagery and style are exactly what his stories were liberally dosed with. The trick is, he was writing about computer stuff that was just around the corner. My fellow techies didn't have particular names for things, so adopting Gibson technospeak like deck, construct, and icebreaker was par for the course. Reading this book 30 years later, the majority of the technobabble is still a reasonably good fit - though I can see how some would be lost.

The story itself is a heist, a favorite situation to read or watch. Case experiences a lot of character growth, especially since he was near bottom at …

Jonathan Eig: Birth of the Pill (2015, Norton & Company, Incorporated, W. W.)

Review of 'Birth of the Pill' on 'Goodreads'

Very thorough history of the decade covering the development of the birth control pill and the four principals involved. People and processes are examined in detail, and the social impact (especially with the Catholic Church) is also a major topic. My favorite part was the FDA examiner who, despite personal and religious objections, did his job and eventually approved the Pill. "When it came to his job at the FDA, his faith and personal opinions were irrelevant."

This book has been favorably compared to [b:The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks|6493208|The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks|Rebecca Skloot|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1327878144s/6493208.jpg|6684634]. For me, this book goes into more depth but ends up with less of a narrative. Where Rebecca Skloot found and interviewed both family members and patients, Jonathan Eig sticks to historical documents.

That said, my summary is pretty much the same. A great history, thought provoking in process and consequences. Recommended.