Reviews and Comments

Thom Locked account

Thom@kirja.casa

Joined 2 years, 8 months ago

At any given time, I am probably reading one book in paper form, another as an audio book, and another on an e-reader. I also keep an anthology or collection in my car, for those long waits. My average rating is between 3 and 4, because I try to seek out good books and authors. One goal is to read all the SF award winners and SF Masterworks. See my profile at Worlds Without End.

Finally, the "social media" info - I am a long-time reader, proud to have completed several summer reading programs as a kid. I recall reading more than 50 books one summer. When I'm not reading, you might find me gaming (board and role play) or working, either as a baseball umpire or with software.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Martin Dugard: The Last Voyage of Columbus (Paperback, 2006, Back Bay Books)

The Year is 1500. Christopher Columbus, stripped of his title Admiral of the Ocean Seas, …

Review of 'The Last Voyage of Columbus' on 'Goodreads'

This book starts with an overview of pre-voyage stuff that jumps around a bit in time - governor Columbus arrested and returned in chains to Spain; Columbus asking both Portugal and Spain to sponsor his first expedition; other expeditions (some launched by the Spanish sovereigns to avoid giving Columbus too much profit), etc. This portion is interesting and brings out the major players, even if it is a bit hard to follow.

The second section dives in to the fourth voyage and covers it in great detail. I missed the earlier what came before or after style here. Notably missing - Portugal, specifically King João II - such a nemesis in the first section of the book.

The book concludes in a rush, giving almost no detail of the final years of Christopher Columbus. A brief history of some of the other players is given. A solid 3½ stars.

Katherine Rundell: Rooftoppers (2013)

When authorities threaten to take Sophie, twelve, from Charles who has been her guardian since …

Review of 'Rooftoppers' on 'Goodreads'

This is the story of Sophie, a baby found floating in a cello case after her ship sinks. The first few chapters tell growth into a strong 12 year old character; the subsequent chapters her adventures on the run. Together they make up a wonderfully endearing story.

First off, Charles (guardian of Sophie) has all the best lines. One of many great bon mots from this character - "I know these sorts of people. They're not men. They're mustaches with idiots attached." He provides a strong male character, guiding without taking over the story. Other supporting characters arrive later on, each well detailed an interesting. One quibble - the few antagonists are mere cardboard cutouts; this is more a tale of adventure than of conflict.

The setting the rooftops of Paris, beautifully described and a solid part of the story. The language and length are perfect for a young adult …

Sy Montgomery: The soul of an octopus (2015)

"In this astonishing book from the author of the bestselling memoir The Good Good Pig, …

Review of 'The soul of an octopus' on 'Goodreads'

Got this book expecting science on consciousness, intelligence, or instinct. Found instead a memoir / travelogue, with occasional anecdotes about the octopus. Yes, I learned a few things, and the audio book was read by the author. The octopus really is quite alien from us, with neurons in their arms (which can go on living after the death of the head), and I was really hoping to read some new insights about this fascinating species. Less anecdotes, more science.

Nnedi Okorafor: Akata Witch (2011)

Akata Witch (retitled What Sunny Saw in the Flames in Nigeria and the UK) is …

Review of 'Akata Witch' on 'Goodreads'

Wonderful world building by the author, though a bit too dense at times. Not a book you can easily put down and pick up again later. The main characters are quite similar to those in the Harry Potter books, and the ending is similar also - bad guy confrontation told all-in-a-rush. This book is part of a series also, and aimed at young adults.

This book has a strong female main character, and neither focuses on her albinism nor the setting of Nigeria. Maybe it's just me, but I found Rowling's world a bit more accessible and the supporting cast a bit more fleshed out.

Started reading aloud with my daughter, but long breaks between chapters made it very hard to follow - many questions. Read on my own in a few days made for quite an improvement. Looking forward to hearing my daughter's opinion when we finish it.

Cor Van den Heuvel: Baseball haiku (2007, W. W. Norton & Co.)

Review of 'Baseball haiku' on 'Goodreads'

A very good introduction and conclusion, fun intros to each of the poets, and of course Haiku (and Senryu). As the editor points out, the Haiku is uniquely suited to Baseball; especially the pastoral setting and lack of a time limit. My favorite from this volume:

carrying his glove
the boy's dog follows him
to the baseball field

Christopher Reich: Rules of Deception (Hardcover, 2008, Doubleday)

Dr. Jonathan Ransom, world-class mountaineer and surgeon for Doctors Without Borders, is climbing in the …

Review of 'Rules of Deception' on 'Goodreads'

This thriller took a while to really get moving. Starts off with many loose threads, eventually collapsing into one narrative. These threads are confusing, perhaps intentionally obfuscated by the author. Another point of irritation is when the characters have information that the reader doesn't have. Once the narrative of Israel vs Iran (and the organizations pulling those strings) comes out fully, the novel tightens up and runs well. 2½ stars.

Charlie Higson: The Young Bond Series, Book One (Paperback, 2009, Hyperion Book CH)

Review of 'The Young Bond Series, Book One' on 'Goodreads'

The Fleming estate authorized these books, and I think it stays true to James Bond form. Our future agent meets up with a Bond girl (neighbor Wilder Lawless) and a Martini (her horse) and even an Aston Martin. The story started slowly and was somewhat violent for the target audience (young adult). I might read another in the series, but won't go out of my way to find it.

Dirk Hayhurst: The Bullpen Gospels (Paperback, 2010, Citadel Press)

From the humble heights of a Class-A pitcher's mound to the deflating lows of sleeping …

Review of 'The Bullpen Gospels' on 'Goodreads'

Really enjoyed this tale of a year in the minor leagues. Contains sophomoric hijinx, a problematic family life, insights into baseball as a career, and likely considerably less swearing than actually occurs. Okay, maybe a little too much focus on the off field shenanigans, but I did laugh out loud several times. Will definitely look to other books and columns from Mr Hayhurst.

The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes is the final set of twelve (out of a total …

Review of 'The case-book of Sherlock Holmes' on 'Goodreads'

Sherlock was a decent companion through Europe. Just wish I had traveled through Switzerland so I could have tossed this collection over Reichenbach Falls.

At this point in the collection, the author was tired of the character, and while these stories could have branched out and been interesting, they were on the whole just okay.

I look forward to reading some modern takes on the main characters in the near future.

Peter Heller: Painter (2015, Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group)

Review of 'Painter' on 'Goodreads'

Essentially a crime novel from the criminal's perspective. The protagonist is a passionate man, with large passions in everything he does - painting, fishing, and his temper. He is described as looking like Hemingway, and perhaps this caricature is the author's goal. Most chapters start off normal and end up in a passionate rush towards something - like a roller coaster out of control.

The style was choppy also, and really didn't work for me. There is a vast gulf between the spare writing of Hemingway and this sparse but unrefined novel. Moral questions have simple answers, the villains are caricatures of bad (then misunderstood) men. Even the detective is paper thin, providing sparse investigation and moral excuses for the main character. While I can safely say I didn't see the ending coming, in hindsight it was the obvious solution.

Read this as part of "Seattle Reads", taking this book …

Arthur Conan Doyle: His Last Bow (Penguin Popular Classics) (1997, Penguin Books Ltd)

The adventure of Wisteria lodge.--The adventure of the cardboard box.--The adventure of the red circle.--The …

Review of 'His Last Bow (Penguin Popular Classics)' on 'Goodreads'

This is a collection of previously published Sherlock Holmes stories, and thus is more scattered than previous collections. The first story is almost a novella; the last more of a history lesson than the usual Holmes deduction fest. None of the tales were 5 star for me, but all were at least above 2. Average score - 3.5 stars.

Read on a Nook while on the road in Europe, 2015.

Kazuo Ishiguro: Never Let Me Go (2010, Vintage)

Kathy, a clone about to donate all her organs and die, reflects on her past …

Review of 'Never Let Me Go' on 'Goodreads'

Saw the movie first, so the various reveals that crop up throughout the story were not hidden to me. They didn't make the film any better, and the same could be said of the book.

The biggest question in my mind is whether to tag the narrator as unreliable. The entire story is told from her perspective, and bounces around as she remembers various parts to her narrative. Unfortunately it is pretty obvious this is Ishiguro's method for hiding some things until revealed later.

It works as a story, and either the children are all oblivious to their situation or the author didn't want to write about the conflict. Either way, it's a depressing book which was just "okay".

James Gleick: Chaos (1988, Penguin)

Review of 'Chaos: Making a New Science' on 'Goodreads'

Bought this book a few years after it was released, but only read occasional chapters. Today I finished a cover-to-cover reading (including a 2008 afterword by the author) and it was pretty darn good.

The book begins and ends with Edward Lorenz, a weatherman who understood why we can't have long-term weather forecasting. Along the way we touch on Mitchell Feigenbaum and his constants, and Benoit Mandelbrot and his fractal dimensions. Utilizing computers to plot what early mathematicians and physicists suspected was a fantastic breakthrough.

The last few chapters cover some of the fascinating ways an understanding of nonlinear systems translates to cardiac arrhythmia, eye movement and crystallization. The newer afterword barely touched on these, and I want to read more on how the math was applied to these and other facets of modern life (and perhaps quantum mechanics?). I would especially like to read more on turbulence.

Highly recommended …

Review of 'Lucky man' on 'Goodreads'

Listened to this on my drive across state. Read by the author (yay) and abridged (boo). A rambling memoir between career and disease and coping with both. I enjoyed parts of this book despite the writing style. Wouldn't seek out the unabridged version. Learned a lot about Parkinson's Disease. Now have a strong desire to rewatch Family Ties. Overall rating - liked it but didn't love it.

reviewed The day of the triffids by John Wyndham (A Modern Library 20th century rediscovery)

John Wyndham: The day of the triffids (2003, Modern Library)

When Bill Masen wakes up blindfolded in hospital there is a bitter irony in his …

Review of 'The day of the triffids' on 'Goodreads'

Excellent book describing the survival of one man, this story is told entirely from his perspective. This apocalyptic tale was written 65 years ago and holds up quite well today.

The planning and travel to a safer location remind me of [b:The Death of Grass|941731|The Death of Grass|John Christopher|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309962069s/941731.jpg|797220], though competition was more fierce in that tale. The latter parts of the book describe years passing, much like the narrative of [b:Earth Abides|93269|Earth Abides|George R. Stewart|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1320505234s/93269.jpg|1650913]. Also like that book, these characters spend a lot of time collecting stored food from the previous civilization. In comparison to those two books, this one had a stronger story line and better characters (motivations and growth). Female characters are also well written.

I wanted to know more about the Triffids, and how (or whether) they were connected to the green flashes. Various characters speculate that they were not, but the topic is not …