Reviews and Comments

Thom Locked account

Thom@kirja.casa

Joined 2 years, 8 months ago

At any given time, I am probably reading one book in paper form, another as an audio book, and another on an e-reader. I also keep an anthology or collection in my car, for those long waits. My average rating is between 3 and 4, because I try to seek out good books and authors. One goal is to read all the SF award winners and SF Masterworks. See my profile at Worlds Without End.

Finally, the "social media" info - I am a long-time reader, proud to have completed several summer reading programs as a kid. I recall reading more than 50 books one summer. When I'm not reading, you might find me gaming (board and role play) or working, either as a baseball umpire or with software.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Isaac Asimov: The Stars, Like Dust (2009)

The Stars, Like Dust is a 1951 science fiction mystery book by American writer Isaac …

Review of 'The Stars, Like Dust' on 'Goodreads'

This early novel by Asimov is a fun bit, with the right amount of plots and counterplots. The characters are pretty flat, and the reveal subplot doesn't fit at all - the author agreed, and considers this his worst novel. If this is the worst he wrote, then he is truly one of the masters.

The plot loosely fits within the Foundation empire - but it seems doubtful that Asimov was planning for all this when he wrote it. Probably better to say that the elements were kicking around and this doesn't fit too badly. I thought the idea of "ruling families" was a bit like warlords, or for that matter the big ranches in old westerns.

Bonus - first appearance of the Visi-Sonor and the Neuronic Whip.

Will probably read the other two early Asimov novels soon. 2½ stars.

John Marsden: Tomorrow #1 (2006)

Review of 'Tomorrow #1' on 'Goodreads'

A decent YA book - fast paced and thrilling.

Yes, that was the review I entered for [b:The Hunger Games|2767052|The Hunger Games (The Hunger Games, #1)|Suzanne Collins|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1358275334s/2767052.jpg|2792775] - so perhaps I should compare. But first, I want to compare to Red Dawn - the 1984 original, not the silly remake.

In each, a group of teens deals with a foreign invasion. Red Dawn has a more plausible enemy (Russians) and a more reasonable target (middle America, near Colorado. Tomorrow has a compelling environment (Hell) and more teen relationships. Edge: Red Dawn

As to The Hunger Games - both are a series of books, primarily about teens and romance plays an important part. Both are quick and suspenseful, and each has plausibility problems. I've only read the first book of the Tomorrow series (and am currently watching the film), but I rate these about even - though the Hunger Games movie …

The Rosie Project is a 2013 Australian novel by Australian novelist Graeme Simsion. The novel …

Review of 'The Rosie Project (Don Tillman, #1)' on 'Goodreads'

Read back in April, some as an ebook and the rest as audio. The latter is highly recommended - Dan O'Grady has the perfect deadpan delivery and Australian accent.

Don Tillman doesn't know (or acknowledge) that he has Asperger's. The humor from this romantic comedy doesn't come from that directly, but more from the situations and how people around him deal with him. Into his rigidly constrained life comes the (cliched) Rosie, "the world's most incompatible woman... late, vegetarian, disorganized, irrational".

I enjoyed the humor and found the story clever. While the situation started out a cliche, all the characters were interesting and most grew through the novel. Especially Don, who found love and acceptance, even if he still didn't acknowledge his own limitations. His view of Asperger's as a potential bonus reflects another novel I read recently, [b:The Speed of Dark|96063|The Speed of Dark|Elizabeth Moon|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1320497793s/96063.jpg|1128271]. I think Don puts …

Chris Impey: Beyond: Our Future in Space (2015)

Review of 'Beyond: Our Future in Space' on 'Goodreads'

This excellent book surveys the recent past, present, and future efforts of space exploration, then goes Beyond, to examine the future of humanity. Chris Impey has a refreshingly optimistic outlook and this well written book was a joy to read.

Each of the four parts has many interesting points, some of which I had not encountered. In the first section, the information about the explorer gene was particularly interesting, and in the present his comparison of near-future space travel to the early Internet is especially good. Each major section is preceded by a few paragraphs of fiction, imagining the world of young pioneers, soon headed for space.

The illustrations were mostly small and a few were difficult to read, but all were sourced in the back of the book. This, plus the excellent end notes for each chapter, allowed me to track down additional information. The index in this book …

Stephen Hawking, Lucy Hawking: George's Secret Key to the Universe (2007)

George's Secret Key to the Universe is a 2007 children's book written by Lucy and …

Review of "George's Secret Key to the Universe" on 'Goodreads'

An average story where the boy learns something and saves the world. The science is decent (I would hope so) and plot is okay. The villain is evil and the protagonists good, though that uber-computer Cosmos is a bit over-the-top. Color photos were nice, but the sidebars (on facts, planets and other relevant bits of information) definitely got in the way. They would have been better collected into an appendix or glossary that could be referred to when necessary. Read with daughter (11) and I felt it was a little below her level, both the science and the language. The one new concept from Stephen (information escaping black holes) required help from the uber-computer to fit the story, and felt clumsy. The associated sidebar was very incomplete, even for the age range (light can't escape but particles do?).

Isaac Asimov: Second Foundation (2004, Bantam Books)

Second Foundation is the third novel published of the Foundation Series by American writer Isaac …

Review of 'Second Foundation' on 'Goodreads'

This final book of the original trilogy was weaker than the first two by quite a bit. The first story (Search By the Mule) is more of a conclusion to the cliffhanger from the second book. The second story is a conclusion (of sorts) to the first trilogy. Both stories rely on a convoluted web of reverse psychology (and reverse psychology backfire), and are annoying to read. Perhaps because of these intricacies, the characters are all mostly flat. 2½ stars, rounded up because Isaac Asimov was just so darned smart.

John F. Ross: Enduring Courage (Hardcover, 2014, St. Martin's Press)

From the Introduction...

Rickenbacker lived at a time when the latest machines of the industrial …

Review of 'Enduring Courage' on 'Goodreads'

Definitely one of the better biographies I have ever read. Eddie Rickenbacker was more than just America's Great War Ace of Aces, more than one of the early successful race car drivers. He was first and foremost courageous, his strong will driving everything he did from a very early age. This determination allowed him to rise from mechanic to driver to salesman, enabled him to overcome the class differences among America's first pilots, and finally drove him to survive against all odds not one but two serious mishaps.

This book was part history, part profile, and part thriller, and was all very well written. Noted and discarded are embellishments by earlier ghost writers and even the past colored by Eddie himself; favoring his true history over the stories. Highly recommended!

Van Burnham: Supercade: A Visual History of the Videogame Age 1971-1984 (2001)

Review of 'Supercade: A Visual History of the Videogame Age 1971-1984' on 'Goodreads'

I sought this out for Nick Montfort's contributions and for the subject matter. What I found was a disjointed coffee table book with editing problems and black pages that absorb oils like crazy.

Van Burnham edits the collection and presumably writes the copy for the myriad games (arcade and home) that dot the pages in timeline order between 1971 and 1984. A broad selection of guest authors fill in the rest, and these articles range from fairly interesting to mailed-in copy.

A few of the articles are broken over multiple pages for no reason that I can see, and one of these has the wrong last page listing. This wasn't the only error, as the index had incorrect locations for some of the games.

In summary, some nice information and some nice pictures that trigger a lot of memories, and a presentation that left a lot to be desired. Glad …

Jack Nisbet: The mapmaker's eye (2005, Washington State University Press)

Review of "The mapmaker's eye" on 'Goodreads'

Very interesting history of David Thompson, told primarily with excerpts and artwork from his journals as he charted the course of the Columbia river. Working for various British fur trading companies, the surveyor worked his way back and forth across the Rockies, exploring different routes and eventually reaching the Pacific.

While reading, I often found myself studying the maps, Thompson's and modern versions. The journal excerpts were fascinating, connecting tribes by language and describing the plants, animals, fish and birds he encountered. It is especially interesting that we don't know what all the plants correspond to.

The only thing that would make this fairly comprehensive book better would be representations of the large maps created by Thompson after retiring. Only one is publicly viewable, and images on the internet don't do it full justice.



This is the sixth book in my quest to read from my friend's "10 books that …

Avi: The true confessions of Charlotte Doyle (1990, Orchard Books)

As the only passenger, and the only female, on a transatlantic voyage in 1832, thirteen-year-old …

Review of 'The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle' on 'Goodreads'

I greatly enjoyed this book and it's strong lead character. This is the fifth book in my quest to read from my friend's "10 books that influenced" lists, and being a young-adult book, I read it aloud with my daughter. Her rating is five stars, and here is some of what she had to say:

The book, "The True Confessions Of Charlotte Doyle" was one of the best books I have ever read. it shows the story of a 12-year old girl, who lead a normal life. when she boarded the ship, "The Seahawk" her life changed forever.

"Doing her part like we all was,", the captain echoed in a mocking tone. "Mr. Barlow, you are not young. In all your years have you ever seen, ever heard of a girl who took up crew's work?"


Definitely recommended.

Nevil Shute: On the Beach (Hardcover, 1986, Amereon House)

A novel about the survivors of an atomic war, who face an inevitable end as …

Review of 'On the Beach' on 'Goodreads'

First released 58 years ago, this novel has not aged well. Looking past the science, there is also a disconnect (for me at least) with the people and their mood. I also tried to put myself into that mood, and the story wasn't any better.

An atomic war happened (cobalt bombs) and everyone in the northern hemisphere is most likely dead. The story is told about a range of personalities living in Melbourne Australia, one of the southernmost cities. Scientists have predicted that the clouds of radioactive dust would work their way south, contaminating everything and killing everything on land soon. A small hope is raised partway through the novel and then dashed - everybody is going to die. Random fact - "on the beach" is a Royal Navy term that means "Retired from the Service" - very fitting here.

The majority of the characters in this novel face that …

Nick Montfort: 10 PRINT CHR$(205.5+RND(1));:GOTO 10 (2013, MIT Press)

Review of '10 PRINT CHR$(205.5+RND(1));:GOTO 10' on 'Goodreads'

Deconstruction of a single line maze generation program in Commodore 64 Basic. A ten author collaboration that is mostly interesting. The discussions of what makes a maze and diversions into textiles were not terribly interesting; the deconstruction of an assembly version of the same code was fascinating. Comprehensive list of sources, plenty of relevant illustrations. Would mostly be a good book to base an intro to programming course on.

A. S. King: Glory O'Brien's history of the future (2014)

"As her high school graduation draws near, Glory O'Brien begins having powerful and terrifying visions …

Review of "Glory O'Brien's history of the future" on 'Goodreads'

Half of this book is teen issues. Glory is a mature 17 year old, whose mother committed suicide. She has just graduated from high school. Her best friend lives across the street in a commune, and occasionally needs help buying chemical products and processed foods. Glory describes this friend as selfish and needy, but this doesn't really come out in her actions. Unfortunately, this half of the story starts off very rough, though it does improve somewhat towards the end. Call it 3 stars.

The other half of the book is the strange future that Glory sees after ingesting the dust of a mummified bat mixed in her beer. These visions reveal an anti-feminist future, where "moronic dipshits" have somehow voted women out of the workplace in response to an "equal pay for women" law. This leads to a civil war, women enslaved as breed stock, and so on. Perhaps …

Christopher Moore: Lamb (2003, Harper Paperbacks)

The birth of Jesus has been well chronicled, as have his glorious teachings, acts, and …

Review of 'Lamb' on 'Goodreads'

Often sacrilegious, somewhat silly and mostly humorous. This book does portray the history well (Sicarii, Essenes and Zealots, oh my!) and tackles the "missing years" in a way that fits the story beautifully. Played more for humor are the parts where the Biff invents the Latte, kitchen matches and sarcasm. While occasionally absurd, the two main characters have a great relationship, and both grow considerably over the course of the novel.

Christopher Moore has described this as his favorite book; I look forward to trying one of his more fictional tales soon.