Reviews and Comments

Thom Locked account

Thom@kirja.casa

Joined 2 years, 8 months ago

At any given time, I am probably reading one book in paper form, another as an audio book, and another on an e-reader. I also keep an anthology or collection in my car, for those long waits. My average rating is between 3 and 4, because I try to seek out good books and authors. One goal is to read all the SF award winners and SF Masterworks. See my profile at Worlds Without End.

Finally, the "social media" info - I am a long-time reader, proud to have completed several summer reading programs as a kid. I recall reading more than 50 books one summer. When I'm not reading, you might find me gaming (board and role play) or working, either as a baseball umpire or with software.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Daniel H. Wilson: Robogenesis (2014)

A sequel to the best-selling Robopocalypse is told through a series of narratives that finds …

Review of 'Robogenesis' on 'Goodreads'

The first novel was pretty cataclysmic, but this novel makes it clear it was more apocalyptic. Towns and cities deserted, whole stretches of the countryside empty, humans in "work camps". As if this wasn't dark enough, the villain in this piece makes it darker - wiping out humans, modified and freeborn... pretty much anyone who wasn't the villain.

Most of the characters who lived through the first novel make an appearance. Mechanically, the book is in three sections, each detailing one major group. The third part (Cormac Wallace) was the most interesting to me, and brings the book to it's conclusion.

I didn't feel there was quite enough intro to the characters for this book to stand on it's own. The ending leaves things up in the air completely with regards to the humans, less so for the villains. I'll definitely read the third book, when the author gets around …

Steve Almond: Against football (2014)

Argues that not only is American football hazardous to players' health, and especially to their …

Review of 'Against football' on 'Goodreads'

This short book details, chapter by chapter, the several problems with football as a sport and as a business. Most are well argued, and though the author doesn't provide a solution, he is quite clear on that in the conclusion. He sees his role as provoking discussion.

Like a previous work, the autobiographical parts don't add much for me, and in many cases detract. No actual studies are cited, and there probably are several mentioned in the concussion chapter alone. It would be interesting to count the number of times "I believe" is used in the text.

I found the chapter on military connections most surprising, and the chapter on concussions most depressing. As a late-comer to the game and fandom, it is probably easier for me to step back - but I feel driven to make a bigger difference. This book only makes the arguments. Perhaps the associated website …

When a mysterious man claims to be their uncle and acquires court custody, Tia and …

Review of 'Escape to Witch Mountain' on 'Goodreads'

Saw the Disney movie well before reading the story, but it must be said the villain has a bumbling Disney-esque style. My daughter enjoyed it well enough; I found myself focused on the lack of technology, even though these aliens are more connected with mental powers.

In the end, the story was plausible (first landing in Hungary, chased out by the Communist take-over and now hunted by elements of the US government ... or perhaps a Communist agent?) and the characters were likeable. The Disney movie reduced the political aspects by giving Lucas Deranian a millionaire boss instead. Sequel movies and a TV series pilot followed; the book also has a sequel.

reviewed New watch by Sergeĭ Lukʹi︠a︡nenko (Night watch series -- book five)

Sergeĭ Lukʹi︠a︡nenko: New watch (2014, Harper)

Older and more powerful, Light magician Anton Gorodestsky has risen to the top levels of …

Review of 'New watch' on 'Goodreads'

Briefly, the growth of Anton continues in fascinating ways. Touching on previous books, we also find out some of the nature of the Twilight itself. Some of the page-long observations of Russia are interesting in an additional context, thanks to to the author's outspoken political views, but they still work well in the story.

Mechanically, this is a three-part story, same as previous books. Technically, Anton's timeline is catching up with the modern day, and his random-play disc player has moved to MP3. The supporting cast are lovingly described, and some have definitely grown and changed since the previous books.

This book is easily 4½ stars, and probably closer to 5. Hoping to go back and reread the whole series soon, starting with a decent review of the first book. Also interested in ranking the books within the series - some storylines are better than others.

Review of 'The Silver Sword' on 'Goodreads'

Found this on a list of children's classics, read with daughter (11). The story of a Polish family, broken apart in WWII. The first several chapters are about the father, who escapes from prison and heads for relatives in Switzerland after returning to a rubble-strewn Warsaw. While there, he doesn't find his family but does find a young boy, who takes a Silver Sword (really a letter opener) as a token to prove who he is should he find the other children. The rest of the story is about his three children, left alone after the mother is taken to a detention camp. They find the boy with the sword and make their way to Switzerland also, among many adventures.

The perspective of the Polish family shows much of the war, from Nazi invasion to Russian liberation. As the children travel to Germany, we see the last days of the …

Walter Isaacson: The Innovators (2014)

The Innovators: How a Group of Hackers, Geniuses, and Geeks Created the Digital Revolution is …

Review of 'The Innovators' on 'Goodreads'

This history spans the gamut from Lovelace/Babbage to Page/Brin, emphasizing the collaborative aspect of creation. Each chapter is a set of histories, and as such feels incomplete - but the astute seeker could find more information by hitting the notes and bibliography. The intro and conclusion make the case that only by collaboration does sustained innovation occur, and in that this falls short - few counterexamples are explored. Those drawbacks noted, this is obviously a labor of love for Walter Isaacson. I found the writing style captivating and the research ultra-complete, and I look forward to comparing this to a pending re-read of Steven Levy's [b:Hackers: Heroes of the Computer Revolution|56829|Hackers Heroes of the Computer Revolution|Steven Levy|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1406160795s/56829.jpg|1407224]. It took me a month to read this only because of interruptions.

Harry Harrison: The stainless steel rat gets drafted. (1988, Bantam)

Of all of Harry Harrison's many great books and series, the Stainless Steel Rat series …

Review of 'The stainless steel rat gets drafted.' on 'Goodreads'

Opens well enough, and a few daring escapes later, our hero ends up drafted. After that, it becomes clumsy anti-army kind of stuff. The antagonist is a paper-thin caricature. Few daring escapes, little cleverness, one great character (Mark). There is one more sequel to this, prequel to the original book, and I am hoping for better.

David Guterson: Snow Falling on Cedars (Paperback, 1995, Vintage Contemporaries)

San Piedro Island, north of Puget Sound, is a place so isolated that no one …

Review of 'Snow Falling on Cedars' on 'Goodreads'

One book with many different stories, intertwined. Most were good, some didn't do it for me. The courtroom drama I liked, along with the flashbacks and cross-examinations. The police procedural bits were a little too casual in the beginning and a little too convenient in the end. The romantic (or should I say the Moby Dick) side story was mostly irritating - but probably a better love story than Twilight. The racism (and/or nationalism) was accurate and gave an excellent counterpoint to the main story. The descriptive language was beautiful. Mother nature was, throughout the book, a bitch. I have not seen the movie, and don't plan to.

This is the second book in my quest to read from my friend's "10 books that influenced" lists, and I look forward to discussing it with Kila. For me, this book would have been much better without Ishmael.

Nick Harkaway: Tigerman (2014)

"Sergeant Lester Ferris is a good man in need of a rest. After a long …

Review of 'Tigerman' on 'Goodreads'

Started this book on Saturday January 24th as part of national Readathon day (make #timetoread), and this most appropriate choice drew me in as four hours slipped by. Finishing the book three days later, I found it very good – full of geek and excitement and emotions – but perhaps not Full of Win.

The main characters are the very British Afghan war veteran Sgt. Lester Ferris and the streetwise youth he knows as Robin. This boy provides most of the geek in the book, with references to movies, television and comic books, his evident passion. These two are well developed and interesting, and Lester shows real growth through the story. Supporting characters are also excellently formed – my favorite is Dr. Inoue, the head of a Japanese research project on the island.

The setting is also a character in this novel. Mancreu island is "an unbothered ethnic jumble of …

Irving Wallace: The R document (1976, Simon and Schuster)

Review of 'The R document' on 'Goodreads'

My good friend Dean put this on a list of "10 books that influenced" him. What I found here was a history lesson wrapped in a thriller and decorated with cautionary notes. The antagonist was strong; the protagonist was weak but in the end made powerful connections. I found the history lesson solid and the thriller compelling - I finished the book in two days. Written in the 70s when the crime rate was higher than today, an updated version would probably fight terrorism... Patriot Act, anyone? Overall a very good read.

Review of 'The complete Funky Winkerbean' on 'Goodreads'

One of my favorite cartoon strips as a kid was Funky Winkerbean, especially the band strips. This collection covers the first three years, and I am glad it is finally available. The only thing better would be to have them electronically - this tome weighs in a 2.5 pounds!

Review of 'Pitchers of beer' on 'Goodreads'

On this night of repeating Seattle champions, I finished another book about a team from Seattle that won back-to-back championships (1940 and 1941). In many was, this book was an excellent follow-on to Boys in the Boat - in time period and in historical personalities. The writing is, unfortunately, not as good. The author covers 27 seasons (along with lead in and follow up) and did a fairly decent job of it. The character of Emil Sick, Fred Hutchison and others come through well. The resulting book is a solid 3½ star effort.

reviewed Foundation and Empire by Isaac Asimov (The Foundation Series #2)

Isaac Asimov, France Loisirs: Foundation and Empire (Paperback, 1962, Granada)

Led by its founding father, the great psychohistorian Hari Seldon, and taking advantage of its …

Review of 'Foundation and Empire' on 'Goodreads'

This sequel (and middle book of the trilogy) has two stories and is a pretty quick read. One Seldon crisis is averted and the other missed, but the answer perhaps foreseen. The last book will tell in this SF version of Gibbon's history.

Isaac Asimov continues the theme of good things falling apart, in this case with petty despots taking over the reigns of the Foundation. Similar things are hinted at behind the scenes, with the hero of the first story subsequently reported dead in the slave mines.

Though the middle book, one could stop reading here. While not the most positive characterization of women, the main character of the second story is well written. Worth of 4 stars, if not quite as good as the first book.

Daniel James Brown: The Boys in the Boat

The Boys in the Boat: Nine Americans and Their Epic Quest for Gold at the …

Review of 'The Boys in the Boat' on 'Goodreads'

Well researched historical non-fiction with the pacing of a good mystery. The descriptions of the races are exciting, but this is far more than just good sports writing. Character backgrounds are clear and concise, with surprising connections throughout. Very well written; hope to read more from this author soon.

Sandi Doughton: Full-Rip 9.0 (Paperback, 2013, Sasquash Books)

Scientists have identified Seattle, Portland, and Vancouver as the urban centers of what will be …

Review of 'Full-Rip 9.0' on 'Goodreads'

This really excellent book covers history, science and preparedness for earthquakes and tsunamis in the Pacific Northwest region. From the history, I loved the way they solved, down to the hour, the last major earthquake (magnitude 8.7 to 9.2) in the area. Color images would have been nice. Highly recommended!