Thom reviewed What Is Real? by Adam Becker
Review of 'What is real?' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
Great summary of the state of Quantum Physics, including most of the history from Einstein/Bohr to the present (aka 2018). No math, but references and notes in the back can lead you there. Unfortunately, no simple answer to the title question.
Thought experiments and metaphors give insight into the competing theories. Chapters focus on history and implications, with some chronological overlap. It was interesting to read about papers lost or buried for years, and just how much ostracism the Copenhagen interpretation folks used against anyone who didn't fall in line. This is sold as a "popular science" book, but goes deep enough to really teach - again, with no math or other deep science knowledge required.
I learned a few things, though I graduated with a minor in Physics. I did not know about the steep ramp up of physics after WWII, or the recent decline. The sections on Philosophy …
Great summary of the state of Quantum Physics, including most of the history from Einstein/Bohr to the present (aka 2018). No math, but references and notes in the back can lead you there. Unfortunately, no simple answer to the title question.
Thought experiments and metaphors give insight into the competing theories. Chapters focus on history and implications, with some chronological overlap. It was interesting to read about papers lost or buried for years, and just how much ostracism the Copenhagen interpretation folks used against anyone who didn't fall in line. This is sold as a "popular science" book, but goes deep enough to really teach - again, with no math or other deep science knowledge required.
I learned a few things, though I graduated with a minor in Physics. I did not know about the steep ramp up of physics after WWII, or the recent decline. The sections on Philosophy were unexpected, but I can see the conjunction now - we are talking about Reality after all, and what can't be measured must be surmised. I did not realize early physicists were so involved with the philosophers.
Even in 2018, quantum physics was deeply involved in modern transistors and storage media. Quantum tunneling impacts my work daily, and I would have liked to see more about this impact to the real world. 30 years ago we were talking about Planck limits to measurement, and they don't make an appearance here. String theory is mentioned only at the end. These last two are much deeper than popular science, so I get it.
Recommended. Rating? It's a great history, but I wanted a little more. 4½ stars.