User Profile

Thom Locked account

Thom@kirja.casa

Joined 2 years, 11 months ago

At any given time, I am probably reading one book in paper form, another as an audio book, and another on an e-reader. I also keep an anthology or collection in my car, for those long waits. My average rating is between 3 and 4, because I try to seek out good books and authors. One goal is to read all the SF award winners and SF Masterworks. See my profile at Worlds Without End.

Finally, the "social media" info - I am a long-time reader, proud to have completed several summer reading programs as a kid. I recall reading more than 50 books one summer. When I'm not reading, you might find me gaming (board and role play) or working, either as a baseball umpire or with software.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Glenn F. Williams: Year of the Hangman : George Washington's Campaign Against the Iroquois (2005)

Review of "Year of the Hangman : George Washington's Campaign Against the Iroquois" on 'Goodreads'

The Year of the Hangman (1777) ended in the first third of this very dry book. While true that the Iroquois' semi-alliance with the British started this year, the main focus of this book is the Battle of Wyoming (1778) and the punitive Sullivan Expedition (1779) that followed. While the latter was under George Washington's orders, I hardly agree with the cover subtitle "George Washington's Campaign Against the Iroquois".

The text was factually complete but very dry, illustrations (always on the upper right hand page) inserted sparsely, and the chapters unbroken except into paragraphs. Further breaking into sections (even one blank line) would have facilitated transitions between the British and Continental points of view, which were difficult to follow - especially since each side had Butlers and Clintons. Maps were unremarkable and scarce.

I would not recommend this book to anyone.

reviewed Misenchanted Sword by Lawrence Watt-Evans (Legends of Ethshar (1))

Lawrence Watt-Evans: Misenchanted Sword (Paperback, 1985, Del Rey)

Ethshar and the Northern Empire have been at war for hundreds of years. Hardly anyone …

Review of 'Misenchanted Sword' on 'Goodreads'

The first book from perhaps my favorite fantasy series. The Ethshar books aren't particularly epic or heroic. Magic is another resource, available to those with coin, and society has some differences because of it. When I first read this, I imagined D&D much more like this world than Middle Earth or Narnia.

There are many books set in this world, but each stands alone nicely. This book is more episodic than epic, and the story of a common warrior and a sword enchanted in haste spans over a hundred years. The main character sometimes reacts with his gut, and other times thinks through his plans, much like any of us. In the end, he is both a common and a good man.

Already a successful writer of fantasy and science fiction, Lawrence Watt-Evans wanted to write "something lighter in tone", and I would say he succeeded. According to the author, …