Reviews and Comments

Thom Locked account

Thom@kirja.casa

Joined 2 years, 8 months ago

At any given time, I am probably reading one book in paper form, another as an audio book, and another on an e-reader. I also keep an anthology or collection in my car, for those long waits. My average rating is between 3 and 4, because I try to seek out good books and authors. One goal is to read all the SF award winners and SF Masterworks. See my profile at Worlds Without End.

Finally, the "social media" info - I am a long-time reader, proud to have completed several summer reading programs as a kid. I recall reading more than 50 books one summer. When I'm not reading, you might find me gaming (board and role play) or working, either as a baseball umpire or with software.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Ten-year-olds Ben Silverstein and Pearl Petal have had quite a busy summer as apprentices of …

Review of 'Fairy Swarm' on 'Goodreads'

This final book in the series brings things to a nice conclusion. This story was told from Pearl's perspective, and some definite growth is evident both through the book and the series. The sugar fairies are consistent and, like my daughter, overwhelmed by sweets. The major villain out thought Doctor Woo but was in turn outfoxed by the kids - though his exit was a little silly.

Read aloud with my middle school daughter, this book is perhaps a better fit for late elementary school kids. We both enjoyed the entire series immensely.

Chris Ballard: One shot at forever (2012, Hyperion)

Review of 'One shot at forever' on 'Goodreads'

Great book - how has it not been made into a movie yet? High school baseball and hijinks and hippies and heartaches pepper this story about a coach and a team and their unlikely playoff run. Excellent sports writing and research, the people of Macon come alive. Highly recommended!

Paolo Bacigalupi: The drowned cities (2012, Little, Brown and Company)

In a dark future America that has devolved into unending civil wars, orphans Mahlia and …

Review of 'The drowned cities' on 'Goodreads'

I really enjoyed Ship Breaker, and this book is a sort of companion story in the same universe. In that first book, the Drowned City (New Orleans) played the role of destination, standing in for the dystopian future and allowing the author to focus on character and story. In this book, the Cities are front and center and the characterizations not a strong. Still very good, but lacking a bit. Perhaps the more linear story is part of the problem, or maybe because this book is quite a bit darker.

It has been said that this book is Young Adult, and the main characters are all basically kids. In their situation, though, they are basically adults, and only in a few cases is a "kid-like" thought had. While dark, the book is not especially gory, and the Young Adult label is fine.

I look forward to reading some adult fiction …

Peter Korn: Why We Make Things and Why It Matters: The Education of a Craftsman

Review of 'Why We Make Things and Why It Matters: The Education of a Craftsman' on 'Goodreads'

This brief book is roughly one half autobiography, one third history of the craft movement, and one sixth philosophy. Each is interesting - the author was there at the beginning - and a little disjointed. His maker ideology feels like half of a conversation, though I cannot participate or even hear the other half. A solid 2½ stars.

Mark Kurlansky: Salt (2003)

Review of 'Salt' on 'Goodreads'

Been sitting on my shelves for a while; when the library turned up an audio copy, I thought it would be a good time to give it a first read.

Covers the impact of salt through history, touching on science towards the end. I learned a lot about the Basques, Celts, and the names of towns in Europe. The recipes didn't add much, in my opinion. Other people have complained about a lack of references; I'll have to dig up my paper copy to check that. A decent book, a pinch more than 3 stars.

reviewed The Sherlock Holmes book by Leslie S. Klinger (Big ideas simply explained)

Leslie S. Klinger, David Stuart Davies, Barry Forshaw: The Sherlock Holmes book (2015)

Chronicles every case of the world's greatest detective and his assistant Dr Watson. The game …

Review of 'The Sherlock Holmes book' on 'Goodreads'

A story by story walk through the Sherlock Holmes canon of Conan Doyle. In addition to basic plot points, most titles have info about setting, writing, or historical connections. As I spent this year with each of the books in turn, it was an appropriate finish. On the other hand, it's like reading an encyclopedia - perhaps more useful as a reference.

Photos were few, infographics were many. While much of the information is on Wikipedia, the presentation here is quite good. I especially like the listing and mini reviews of other works after A. Conan Doyle's Holmes.

reviewed Pay the piper by Jane Yolen (A rock 'n' roll fairy tale)

Jane Yolen: Pay the piper (2005, Starscape)

When Callie interviews the band, Brass Rat, for her school newspaper, her feelings are ambivalent, …

Review of 'Pay the piper' on 'Goodreads'

Good consistent story with historical connections; the idea of a modern day pied piper ala Ian Anderson makes for a fun read. The wording was a little rough in places, but nothing an edit pass or a little rewording wouldn't fix. Fairly short chapters, made for good bedtime chapter book reading.

Read with daughter, 12, who received the added opportunity to look up a few archaic and obscure words.

Donna Shirley: Managing Martians (1998, Broadway Books)

Review of 'Managing Martians' on 'Goodreads'

A combination of Mars mission narrative - very complete and interesting; biography - quite brief; and team management discussion - the author wrote another book beforehand titled Managing Creativity. Especially interesting were some of the plans for future Mars missions and the authors descriptions of challenges encountered because of gender and her leadership role within JPL.

A spread of black and white photos in the book depict the author, her colleagues and both of the spacecraft.

I sought this book out after reading [b:The Martian|18007564|The Martian|Andy Weir|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1413706054s/18007564.jpg|21825181]. In that story, the Pathfinder and Soujourner both play a pivotal role. While some of the probe facts are not quite accurate (no LEDs, no external power port), it still makes for a great story.

A solid 4½ stars, this book is a quick read and definitely recommended.

Neal Stephenson: Anathem (2008, William Morrow)

Anathem, the latest invention by the New York Times bestselling author of Cryptonomicon and The …

Review of 'Anathem' on 'Goodreads'

A first contact, coming of age, parallel worlds story and philosophical treatise all rolled into one. The voluminous alternate terms had me thinking this would be a chore, but 50 pages in (a mere 1/19th of the tome!) I was rolling with the flow.

Parts of the design I most liked: an isolated monk-like group consisting of both genders and studying math and science instead of religion. The discussions and then examples of living consciousness existing in many "narratives" simultaneously - with knowledge of and ability to change between them! Space travel and the rendezvous with an alien ship.

Yes, there are times when the author dialogues to tell the story, though the main character is a novice for most of the story. That small quibble aside, this is an excellent self-contained work. I look forward to tackling Seveneves and the Baroque Cycle soon.

Review of 'Aesthetic of Play' on 'Goodreads'

Argues for the elimination of the distinction between video games (interactive) and novels / plays / music (passive). Each represents a type of "play", an interaction between the media and the consumer. Touches on Ron Edwards' GNS theories of role playing games and critical analysis as a further form of play.

The author is a video game designer, and the ideas he collects here tie closely into why a video game "works" or doesn't, including when cut-scenes make sense and when the player will be annoyed by them. These same ideas tie into the expectations of the reader of a book, and are revealed in many of the "rules of writing". This book provided a very interesting discourse, with a decent bibliography to match.

reviewed Davy by Edgar Pangborn (Collier nucleus fantasy & science fiction)

Review of 'Davy' on 'Goodreads'

Davy is on a list of defining science fiction books of the 1960s - www.worldswithoutend.com/lists_60s.asp - perhaps because it was so different. Anyhow, the satire is mostly lost, the characters roughshod, and the first five chapters irritating.

The survivors of When Worlds Collide find themselves struggling to establish a new society on …

Review of 'After Worlds Collide' on 'Goodreads'

Also short, this novel is more nationalism than science fiction, though it did correctly line up the future opponents of the USA.

The first part here echoes and continues the previous story - landing on the new planet, setting up camp, exploring, finding lush farmland and remnants of a former civilization. Then a plane flies overhead, and the novel kicks off in a different direction.

Russian, Japan and Germany banded together to build a separate ark, and from the moment they landed, they started investigating the former civilization. Everything is learned to further exploitation, leading to outright conflict later in the story. The American team slowly investigates a domed city (did Rendezvous with Rama draw from this?) and starts to learn things, though way behind the bad guys.

This conflict wraps up quickly in the last two chapters, one of which is titled "Justice Tips the Scales". While the people …

John Christopher: The White Mountains (Hardcover, 2014, Aladdin)

Young Will Parker and his companions make a perilous journey toward an outpost of freedom …

Review of 'The White Mountains' on 'Goodreads'

Somehow missed this series when I was a kid; really enjoyed this author's The Death of Grass and thought the prequel novel was pretty good too.

Teen Will lives in a world that has regressed considerably due to the foreign influence of the Tripods. In a society without serious science or decent propulsion, Will is certain of only one thing - he doesn't want to be "Capped". Nobody in this book knows what the caps do, but they suspect an unswerving loyalty to the overlord aliens.

Will escapes to the south, reluctantly joined by his cousin and later by another boy called Beanpole (a derivation of his French name, Jean-Paul). Their adventures are well described and episodic, culminating in a run to the south and a battle with one of the Tripods.

The first of a series, this book comes to a rather abrupt end, with a two page summary …

Daniel H. Wilson, John Joseph Adams: Press Start to Play

Review of 'Press Start to Play' on 'Goodreads'

Great anthology; glad I could renew it at the library. All the stories have something to do with video games, and quite a few are connected to female gamers. Especially liked the more horror focused stories - All of the People in Your Party Have Died and Desert Walk. The latter reminded me of Desert Bus - if you haven't heard of that, go read about it NOW! Many of the other stories were also darn good. My overall favorite (and not just because I played Trade Wars and hosted a BBS so my friends could play) was Andy Weir's Twarrior. Overall result - collection recommended!

Graham Moore: The Sherlockian (2010)

Review of 'The Sherlockian' on 'Goodreads'

Chapters alternate between modern day and the time of Arthur Conan Doyle in this double mystery, each with a basis in historical fact. The author's descriptions are evocative, and I loved the suggestions (from Bram Stoker) to "keep Holmes in the gaslight". Each chapter starts with a relevant Holmes quote, and an author's note at the end details where the history stops. Really enjoyed this!