Reviews and Comments

Thom Locked account

Thom@kirja.casa

Joined 2 years, 8 months ago

At any given time, I am probably reading one book in paper form, another as an audio book, and another on an e-reader. I also keep an anthology or collection in my car, for those long waits. My average rating is between 3 and 4, because I try to seek out good books and authors. One goal is to read all the SF award winners and SF Masterworks. See my profile at Worlds Without End.

Finally, the "social media" info - I am a long-time reader, proud to have completed several summer reading programs as a kid. I recall reading more than 50 books one summer. When I'm not reading, you might find me gaming (board and role play) or working, either as a baseball umpire or with software.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Robert A. Heinlein: Space cadet (2005, Tor)

A young man reports for the final tests for appointment as a cadet in the …

Review of 'Space cadet' on 'Goodreads'

This was the second Heinlein juvenile, published only a few years after World War II. Set 125 years in the future, after the first exploration and colonization of several planets, our solar system still provides a wonderful playground for the characters. Cell phones make an appearance, along with several other decent guesses about the future of technology.

Predating Starship Troopers and The Forever War, it tells of a group of young men going through cadet training for the Space Patrol. Humor and honor go hand in hand here, with a strong emphasis on morality and service. While the conditions on Venus aren't up to today's information, most of the novel does use fairly hard science to describe maneuvers and solutions.

Originally chosen to read with my daughter on a whim (more classic science fiction is always good), she really enjoyed this book and especially the characters.

Harper Lee: To Kill a Mockingbird (Paperback, 2015, Arrow Books)

'Shoot all the Bluejays you want, if you can hit 'em, but remember it's a …

Review of 'To Kill a Mockingbird' on 'Goodreads'

This book (and the Gregory Peck movie) go in the category of "things I somehow missed in high school". I knew the rough storyline and was familiar with the characters, but that's about it.

Really enjoyed my time reading this tale. Especially well crafted was how the story of the trial bumped along at the edge of Scout's narrative for the first third of the book. Truly a timeless classic.

reviewed The black cloud by Fred Hoyle (Penguin Classics)

Fred Hoyle, Fred Hoyle: The black cloud (Paperback, 2010, Penguin Books)

Review of 'The black cloud' on 'Goodreads'

A massive black cloud approaches the solar system, with calculations and estimations laid out as part of the text. The first 2/3 is a high realism disaster novel, between boiling layers of atmosphere and massive temperature drop from lack of sunshine.

The whole novel reads like a screenplay, though I suspect Hollywood would remove the calculus. This ensemble piece doesn't have a main character, though cold-hearted scientist Professor Kingsley (apparently modeled after the author) comes close. The primary setting of Nortonstowe has a very British feel.

A very enjoyable book.

Steven Levy, Steven Levy: Hackerlar (Paperback, Turkish language, 2010, ODTÜ Yayıncılık)

Today, technology is cool. Owning the most powerful computer, the latest high-tech gadget, and the …

Review of 'Hackerlar' on 'Goodreads'

In the early eighties, Apple II aficionado Steven Levy wrote a history of the early personalities involved in computers. Most of them considered themselves at one time Hackers, that is living by the Hacker Ethic. Roughly speaking, this regards access to computers and information as paramount, judging all by their skills and talents with computers - not their salaries or station in life.

I read this history in the summer after high school, having had a taste of TRS-80 and timeshare computers at school, plus a TI-99 at home. In these pages I found a creed that I could thrive on. This re-read some 30 years later shows me some of the cracks in the foundation - the journalism and editing could have been a smidge better. The lens focuses on Apple, with Commodore, PC and TRS-80 getting only a few mentions. That said, I am still amazed by the …

Ritter, Lawrence S.: The glory of their times (1992, Quill, William Morrow)

Review of 'The glory of their times' on 'Goodreads'

As relevant today as it was in 1966 and it will be in 2066. Filled with stories and pictures from the deadball era, as told through the recollections of several players who were there.

In the introduction, the author tells us the idea for this collection came to him on the death of Ty Cobb, widely regarded as one of the greatest players in baseball history. The resultant book is a top baseball bestseller and the original audio tapes are themselves in the baseball hall of fame.

This rating is based on the enlarged edition, published in 1984, and frequently re-read. This reading is of the audio version from the library, which is a subset of the original tapes with Larry Ritter's introductions. It ends with John "Chief" Meyers reading Casey at the Bat.

Richard Matheson: The Shrinking Man (Paperback, 2003, Gollancz)

Review of 'The Shrinking Man' on 'Goodreads'

In the last week, I've read two science fiction books from the fifties, and while they share many similarities, the experience was vastly different.

Both spawned a cultural trope - pod people and shrinking people. Both were added to the Science Fiction Masterworks series and each resulted in successful films. A lesson was implied in these stories, though that could probably be said of much science fiction of this era. Both books have rather questionable science, from pods that grow rapidly (and float into the sky!) to a poisoning process that causes a loss of 1/7th of an inch per day, never stopping or varying. The difference was that in one, disbelief could be willingly suspended.

While I thoroughly enjoyed the Invasion of the Body Snatchers, finishing it in a day, I found myself avoiding The Shrinking Man. I liked the main character of the former - a creative and …

Carl Sagan: Pale Blue Dot (Paperback, 1995, Random House)

Pulitzer Prize-winning author Carl Sagan traces our exploration of space and suggests that our very …

Review of 'Pale Blue Dot' on 'Goodreads'

Published posthumously, Pale Blue Dot is a sober look at space exploration and climate stewardship, closely counting the costs of each. It was also regarded as a sequel of sorts to Cosmos, and is similarly a survey of several sciences.

All alliteration aside, this was a book I have been meaning to read for a long time. I really appreciated the comparison between "wanting to fly in space" and the more practical "robots can do a lot" accounting. For a book published 20 years ago, most of the science is spot on, and we've seen the results of some of the missions that were just in the planning stages here. What I really wanted was a few more benefits, a more positive outlook - this book unfortunately pales in comparison to Chris Impey's [b:Beyond: Our Future in Space|22253730|Beyond Our Future in Space|Chris Impey|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1415581087s/22253730.jpg|41629757].

Jack Finney: Invasion of the body snatchers (1989, Simon & Schuster)

Review of 'Invasion of the body snatchers' on 'Goodreads'

Started this last night, finished the last few chapters this morning. A very quick read, the story keeps driving forward. A caveat - I haven't seen any of the movies. Scenes and sections only.

The Body Snatchers was originally published in three parts in Collier's magazine. The main character is Dr Miles Bennell, and the novel is told entirely from his perspective. While not the first to encounter the pods, he is in the right spot to put pieces of the story together. In the process of doing this, he vacillates in a very human way about the best way to deal with this - he strongly considers giving up more than once. In the end, though, it is his resistance that saves the day.

The version I read was the author's 1978 edit of the novel, with a few minor changes (Santa Mira became Mill Valley, the year moved …

Review of 'Kon-Tiki' on 'Goodreads'

This love story between and a man and his raft and their journey nearly 70 years ago doesn't end well for the raft.

This book is the true story of one man's unwavering belief in his theory of South Pacific migration from South America, and his willingness to risk his own life to prove it. Comes across as a true adventure tale, a thrill to read and hard to put down. Recommended!

Roy Scranton: Learning to die in the Anthropocene : reflections on the end of a civilization (2015, City Lights Books) No rating

Coming home from the war in Iraq, US Army private Roy Scranton thought he'd left …

Review of 'Learning to die in the Anthropocene : reflections on the end of a civilization' on 'Goodreads'

No rating

Through the first half the author focuses on proving the climate change point, disregarding modification options that don't prove his point. Though the intro was good, I got tired of waiting for him to get to that point - and other reviews indicate that it comes much later.

Review of 'Trouble on Titan' on 'Goodreads'

Likely compared to the Heinlein juveniles which were published around the same time, I found this story to be quite a bit better. Ten years later, RAH would dedicate his novel Farnham's Freehold to Alan E. Nourse, and Trouble on Titan was his first published full-length work.

The descriptions of Titan are darn close to what probes found fifty years after this book was published, even though the silicon life forms are a bit fanciful. Women could have played a stronger role here, especially as the colony was described as balanced. The story works well, even though the villain is mostly a cliche. There is a good reason this novel was included in the Winston science fiction series (juvenile novels with a focus on science) and James Wallace Harris' "Defining Science Fiction Books of the 50s" list.

Definitely looking forward to reading more from the late Alan Nourse in the …

Michael Witwer: Empire of Imagination: Gary Gygax and the Birth of Dungeons & Dragons (2015)

Review of 'Empire of Imagination: Gary Gygax and the Birth of Dungeons & Dragons' on 'Goodreads'

A collection of scenes from the life and business of E. Gary Gygax. Not a true biography - whole incidents take place between the scenes, and are not explained. More a history of Gary leading to a history of Dungeons and Dragons. There were a few anecdotes I hadn't read, and I was surprised just how instrumental he was in starting and then building GenCon.

A solid 2.4 stars, but rounded up on the Gem Appreciation table to a 3.

Cory Doctorow: For the Win (Hardcover, 2010, Tor Teen)

Young adult science fiction set in the present or near future. The characters are "gold …

Review of 'For the Win' on 'Goodreads'

Cory Doctorow mashes together a story about gold farming and how it relates to global economies with lectures on financial markets and labor unions. It feels like a decent story could have come from one or the other, but both together (and a handful of characters for each) makes for a way-too-long slog. [b:Pirate Cinema|13539171|Pirate Cinema|Cory Doctorow|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1337400827s/13539171.jpg|13238987] and [b:Little Brother|954674|Little Brother (Little Brother, #1)|Cory Doctorow|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1349673129s/954674.jpg|939584] were so good, leaving this book only so-so.

Kudos to the author for some realistic and fairly creative descriptions of online games that don't exist (yet). Groans to the author for using a waggled chin 19 times - I didn't search for variations on that.

Grady Hendrix: Horrorstor (2014)

Review of 'Horrorstor' on 'Goodreads'

Humor for the first half, horror for the last half - enjoyed the former more than the latter. I won't ever look at a flatpack cabinet the same way again. The first half of the epilog seemed long, but I liked where it ended up.

Graeme Simsion: The Rosie Effect (2015)

The Rosie Effect is a 2014 novel by Australian novelist Graeme Simsion and the second …

Review of 'The Rosie Effect' on 'Goodreads'

Where the first book was a wonderful romantic comedy, this sequel is a bad situation comedy.

Quirky Don Tillman gets into various scrapes, tells lies, and hides his escapades from his wife. Chapters read like episodes, mostly wrapping up with an improbable (yet convenient) solution. Rosie, once a vibrant character, becomes little more than a caricature, accepting most of Don's exploits with little comment. For part of the story, she is impersonated by another character in the book - a standard TV trope. My overall rating is very disappointing, with a strong recommendation to read only the first book (which is wonderful).

Finally, a note to other reviewers who blanch at giving this one star (did not like) because it is "too low" - see my "abandoned" shelf, which is very much the equivalent of zero stars. While I did not abandon this book, I was definitely tempted.