Reviews and Comments

Enum & Valerie

enumeration@kirja.casa

Joined 3 years ago

@vivavaleria@eldritch.cafe on the mammooth site. Reading mostly wlw rom-coms, with the occasional exceptions. I try to rotate languages, but it isn't really easy to find queer romance books in other languages than English. Reviews and comments usually in the same language as the book.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Andrea Lawlor: Paul takes the form of a mortal girl (Hardcover, 2019, Picador)

A Guide to US-American 90s Queer Cultures

Damn this book felt long and boring. Mostly, nothing happens except that Paul/Polly moves around Iowa City/Michigan/Provincetown/San Francisco and fucks around. No tension, no bigger story. I do have to appreciate however, how this book visits quite some different sides and forms and subcultures of gay and lesbian communities. Paul's shapeshifting allows it.

Casey McQuiston: The Pairing (Hardcover, MacMillan)

Theo and Kit have been a lot of things: childhood best friends, crushes, lovers and …

American view on Europe

Let me first stress how fucking American this is. The entire book plays during a “European Food and Wine Tour”, with the following stops: London, Paris, Bordeaux, Saint-Jean-de-Luz, San Sebastián, Barcelona, Nice, Monaco, Cinque Terre, Pisa, Florence, Chianti, Rome, Naples and Palermo. Because, of course, food and wine culture only exists in France, Northern Spain, Italy and .... London.

Oh, no, excuse me, London is not a proper stop on this tour. There's no food and wine served in London. The tour only starts in London, and the first thing they do on the tour is a bus ride to Paris. Wait what? Who the fuck travels to London first, if the real start is Paris? One of the protagonists actually even lives in Paris, but travels to London for the tour start and the bus ride to Paris. Holy hell.

Of course, there are Europeans on the tour (from …

Isabel Abedi: Isola (Hardcover, 2010)

Zwölf Jugendliche, drei Wochen allein auf einer einsamen Insel vor Rio de Janeiro - als …

Jugenderinnerungen

Ich erinnere mich noch genau, wie ich dieses Buch früher im Sommer-Lese-Club der lokalen Bücherei verschlungen habe, und ich habs damals geliebt. Als ich es dann Ende letzten Jahres unter den aussortierten Büchern einer anderen Bücherei gesehen habe, musste ich es einfach mitnehmen, und nochmal lesen ♥

Casey McQuiston: Red, White & Royal Blue (Paperback, 2019, St. Martin's Griffin)

What happens when America's First Son falls in love with the Prince of Wales?

When …

The bar is too high

This is a good book, for what it is. However, not much of it is really unique and mindfuckingly excellent. In fact, Casey McQuiston's other books, specifically One Last Stop and I Kissed Shara Wheeler, are full of such amazing ideas and moments, that Red, White & Royal Blue just cannot keep up. They've set the bar too high.

Then again, AFAIK, Red, White & Royal Blue is McQuiston's first book, so one could see this as evidence that they only get better and better.

Adiba Jaigirdar: Rani Choudhury Must Die (Paperback, 2024, Hachette Children's Group)

Cute light read

... as always with Adiba Jaigirdar's books. I like her writing style and can consume book after book of hers.

However, I just really dislike mono people's obsession with "cheating" and the entire drama and demonization about it. I don't get it, really, not at all. Yup, some guys are absolute jerks, and I love stories where the girls just team up and date each other instead. But is Zak's bigest flaw really that he had some dates with someone else?

Also, since when is app coding the top notch discipline of science? And usually spyware is an instrument of shitty dudes, not against them.

Jennifer Dugan: Playing for Keeps (Hardcover, 2024)

June is the star pitcher of her elite club baseball team—with an ego to match—and …

Nice read

Though I didn't really like the plot structure. In romance novels, I like extensive, well-engineered falling-in-love-montages, and this one didn't really have any. Instead, it's all about the first conflict, which isn't really that deep, and could've been solved within 10 minutes of just talking to each other. Honestly, why?

Lee Miye: The Dallergut Dream Department Store (Paperback, 2020)

Magical world full of good vibes

Ever wondered where your mind wanders when you're asleep, and where the dreams come from? There's a whole world of dreammakers and supply chains who can deliver you exactly what you need. The book is full of little stories about different dreamers and dreammakers and life in the shop, and it's all a feel-good atmosphere.

Kika Hatzopoulou: Hearts That Cut (2024, Penguin Young Readers Group)

She cuts the thread and the world ends.

I absolutely loved Threads That Bind, so I was very excited for this sequel. And it was so good! She really managed to find a continuation and an ending that is actually satisfying! Oh also, I didn't really like the "love is fate" stuff in the first book, but this sequel finally gets over it!

reviewed Laylayland by Christian Vogt (Wasteland, #2)

Christian Vogt, Judith Vogt: Laylayland (Paperback, deutsch language, Plan9-Verlag)

Laylay und Zeeto reisen durch das Ödland auf der Suche nach einer Möglichkeit, Zeetos Leben …

So schön trashig

Und so schön viel linke Kultur darin. Was ich weniger appreciate ist dass allen ernstes irgendsoeine Universal-KI die Rettung sein soll die mal eben alles löst. Come on...

Amalia Zeichnerin: Regency Park (German language)

Der Schauspieler Leo beginnt einen Job als Kleindarsteller in dem historischen Themenpark „Regency Park” und …

Leider etwas flache Plots

Pluspunkt allerdings für »sier« bei einem der Hauptcharaktere. Ansonsten liest es sich wie ein früher Entwurf zu einem Buch, das noch ein paarmal durch Lektorat und Revisionen gehen muss.

Becky Albertalli: Imogen, Obviously (2023, HarperCollins Publishers Limited)

Imogen Scott has questions…

Imogen Scott may be hopelessly heterosexual, but she’s got the World’s …

Amazing, obviously

Okay, maybe not obviously. In fact, this is the first Albertalli book that I actually like. But it is amazing, and I've read it in just two days.

Oh, btw, from the beginning it looks like this is a cheap girl-stumbles-into-the-wrong-conversation-and-jumps-to-conclusions-and-throws-away-everything plot - don't worry, it's not. It's really not :3

I also loved all the references to other sapphic authors. Casey McQuiston is named explicitely many times, and Imogen has three copies of One Last Stop in her bookshelf. The teacher is called Ms Dugan. And the book is dedicated to Sophie Gonzales. I love stuff like this, it's so cute. It's what I usually read the Acknowledgements chapters for (which I love).